TL;DR
- On Michigan's Great Lakes shoreline, distinguish the statutory ordinary high-water mark from the natural mark and today's water edge. They need not coincide.
- Obtain the existing seawall or dock's actual authorization, plans and conditions. A structure being present does not establish its regulatory history or permission for replacement.
- Ask EGLE about the actual location and proposed work, including separate federal authorization and any bottomland conveyance question. One document does not answer every permission.
- Keep an unverified shoreline feature or repair plan out of the property's assured usable-value assumptions until the records and qualified assessment support it.
Ask where the shoreline feature sits, not just where the water is
A buyer considering a Michigan Great Lakes house should resolve both location and authorization before counting a seawall, dock or beach-work plan as an available asset. A photograph taken at low water cannot answer either question.
EGLE's ordinary-high-water-mark guidance explains that Part 325 uses statutory elevations referenced to a datum. It separately describes the natural mark left by sustained water presence, such as a soil or vegetation change. The agency says the two marks may occur in different places and water can rise above both.
Ask an appropriately qualified professional what location evidence and elevation reference are needed for the feature and intended work. Retain the datum with any elevation, rather than comparing bare numbers from different references. This guide establishes neither the parcel boundary nor public and private ownership rights.
Match the existing structure to its actual documents
Request the available permits, approved drawings, conditions, amendments, completion or inspection records and relevant ownership documents. Match the location and structure described in those records to what is actually present. Have discrepancies evaluated rather than inferring that a different-looking seawall is covered by the old paperwork.
EGLE's Great Lakes construction-permit page identifies activities such as fill, dredging, docks, boat lifts and seawalls below the statutory mark as permit matters. It also warns that work above the mark can require permission under other statutes. Ask the county's EGLE staff about the actual site and scope; do not turn “above the water” into an exemption.
Existing authorization and permission for a new repair, replacement or enlargement are different questions. Describe the proposed work accurately, including its location and changes, and ask the responsible offices what is required. This is not a permit determination or a repair design.
Keep construction permission and bottomland use separate
EGLE says Great Lakes projects requiring its permit also require a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers permit. Its page describes joint application routing, but routing an application is not evidence that either agency has approved the actual work.
The page also says projects involving long-term occupation and use of Great Lakes bottomlands may require a conveyance. Ask EGLE and the appropriate legal adviser whether that question applies, which documents exist, and what ownership or transfer review this purchase needs. Do not call every dock a conveyance case or assume the construction permit itself resolves the property interest.
Build a feature-to-authority worksheet
| Evidence | Buyer question | Keep separate |
|---|---|---|
| Feature location and elevation reference | Where is the existing or proposed work relative to the relevant mark? | Today's water edge versus the statutory and natural marks |
| Existing plans and authorizations | Does the document describe this actual structure and scope? | Presence versus documented authorization |
| Conditions and completion records | What conditions were imposed and what remains unresolved? | A permit issued versus work documented as completed |
| Proposed repair or replacement | Which offices must evaluate this version of the work? | Old permission versus a changed design |
| Bottomland-use documents | Is a conveyance or transfer question applicable? | Construction permission versus a property-use interest |
| Specialist assessment and price | What condition, work, exclusions and timing are supported? | Regulatory records versus physical condition and cost |
Keep full documents and the dates of agency responses. This original worksheet does not establish that an existing feature is lawful or transferable.
Price only the shoreline use the evidence supports
Invented illustration: a buyer values a house assuming the old dock can be enlarged and the seawall replaced in the same position. The seller supplies a photograph and an old permit without drawings. The buyer still lacks a location comparison, an assessment of the actual structures and a response about the proposed work. The supported purchase case cannot silently treat all three as settled.
Ask for the missing documents and qualified scopes. Compare the deal without the unsupported enlarged dock benefit, while retaining the investigation and any identified work costs. Update the purchase cost sheet and keep unresolved conditions in the closing handoff.
EGLE sources checked November 20, 2026. No parcel-specific mark, ownership finding, permit outcome or approval timeline is established. For practice resolving acquisition assumptions, explore Deal 90.
Practice the skills that move a deal forward
Explore the Deal 90 program and see whether coached practice and deal support fit the part of your acquisition process you need to improve.
Explore Deal 90