Assessed value is a value established within a jurisdiction's tax system. An automated valuation model, or AVM, estimates property value using a model. Neither number, by itself, tells a local house buyer what a particular house will sell for in its current condition.
Homebase concluded that the evaluated property-data providers were equivalent at the source-data layer for our local buying purposes, so we brought sifting, derivatives and stacking in-house around the buyer's strategy. The distinction between a county value and a modeled estimate is part of that decision: useful source facts and useful calculations need different interpretation, even when they arrive in the same record.
TL;DR
- Read the county's definition and value year before comparing assessed values. A tax-system value may use a statutory percentage or another basis.
- An AVM is a modeled estimate. Two models agreeing does not independently establish a property's sale price or condition.
- In our September 2026 16-property diagnostic, ATTOM and PropertyRadar AVMs were within 2% on six properties. We had no appraisal target to decide which was right.
- Test values within the neighborhood and property type the buyer would actually buy, while keeping source values, model estimates and offer analysis separate.
What each value actually represents
A county record can contain several value fields. Do not assume that a field called “assessed” is interchangeable with full cash value, a taxable value, a tax bill or a market estimate.
Arizona makes the distinction explicit: its statute directs assessors to apply the applicable percentage to full cash value or limited property value, as appropriate, to show assessed valuation. That is a jurisdiction-specific rule, not a percentage to apply everywhere. Arizona Revised Statutes § 42-15010
| Number | What it represents | What to check before using it |
|---|---|---|
| County assessed value | A value under the local assessment system | Definition, basis, year and whether it covers land, improvements or both |
| Other county value fields | Values serving specified local tax or valuation purposes | Exact field name and relationship to assessed value |
| AVM | A model's property-value estimate | Estimate date, available confidence information and property match |
| Recorded sale price | A reported transaction amount | Date, transaction type and whether the sale is comparable |
| Buyer offer analysis | A decision based on the proposed purchase and costs | Condition, comparable sales, work needed and the buyer's actual plan |
A source fact can be reliably reported without being today's market price. The fact that a county published a value is different from a claim that a buyer should pay it. Likewise, a polished AVM estimate is still an estimate.
ATTOM's documentation treats assessments and AVMs as separate resources. Confirm the exact fields available in your package rather than substituting one value for another. ATTOM API documentation
Our same-property check found more agreement on buildings than values
On September 30, 2026, we compared ATTOM and PropertyRadar on the same 16 selected properties across five markets. Both supplied year built, floor area and AVMs on all 16. Year built matched exactly on every property. Floor area matched exactly on 15. Their AVMs were within 2% on six properties and differed by more than 2% on 10.
For that comparison, we divided the absolute difference by the larger absolute value; exact equality also counted as agreement. The pairwise counts were recalculated from saved results on November 14, not generated by a new vendor test.
Method and limits: These 16 properties formed a selected diagnostic sample. We had no independent appraisal, measured-area target or verified condition-based value. Access restrictions and differing field dates could matter. Disagreement did not establish which AVM was better, and agreement on building facts did not validate either value model. These results cannot rank current nationwide accuracy.
Compare like with like before judging a provider
Suppose one product returns an assessed value and another returns a different county valuation basis. A large numeric difference may reflect the fields you chose rather than a bad record. First confirm that both figures refer to the same parcel, the same year and the same land-and-building scope.
Then check the county's definitions. Keep the original field name and basis attached to the number in your working notes. Do not silently convert across jurisdictions using a convenient national multiplier. A tax bill is another separate field, affected by the local tax calculation; it is not a substitute for reading the underlying value definition.
For an AVM comparison, align the property and estimate dates as closely as possible. Investigate whether the disagreement would actually change the decision. An estimate that leaves the same homes on a research shortlist has a different operational consequence from one that changes an offer materially.
Test the value field against the local buying task
Build a small review set of comparable homes in the neighborhood and property type you would buy. Include ordinary properties and known exceptions, such as houses needing substantial work. Check building facts, recent relevant sales and what you can establish about condition. Record where a field is missing or where the comparison remains unresolved.
This is a recommended evaluation method, not an additional study we performed. It helps answer whether a value field supports your local research. It does not turn a model comparison into an appraisal or guarantee a profitable offer.
Our Source, Sift, Stack, Skip approach keeps that work tied to the strategy: neighborhood first, then owner audience, then one motivation per list. Homebase's in-house interpretation does not require every motivation to coincide on one house. Combine relevant lists, remove duplicates and do-not-mail entries, refresh before each send and mail consistently.
For the reader choosing a value field, the useful question is specific: does this correctly defined, dated number help identify houses worth researching here? Keep the separate purchase-price decision grounded in the particular property and the buyer's costs.
Direct mail to the neighborhoods where you want to buy
Homebase handles direct mail to property owners in the neighborhoods where you want to buy. Enter one address to find your neighborhood and get your first neighborhood analysis free. No card required.
Analyze a neighborhood free